Meshpoints hosts fortnightly peer learning sessions for innovation facilitators from across regional Western Australia. Recently we discussed the benefits and challenges of facilitating learning programs for entrepreneurs in the regions. In a way, asking “Why would you, and is it worth, running them?”
On the call, facilitators in the Mid West, Great Southern, South West, Perth and Curtin University (Ignition Program) all contributed ideas. We hope sharing them here is useful and welcome your comments.
[This past was co-authored with Katie van den Brand and was first published by Meshpoints]
By learning programs we mean structured learning activities for entrepreneurs and startups. They are most commonly offered in-person at co-working spaces and incubators with some mixed online/offline deliver. Examples of programs include Hackathons (including Startup Weekend), design sprints, Q&A with experts in residence, specialist technical training, pre-accelerator and accelerator programs.
For the ventures the benefits include:
-
Increased confidence, skills and knowledge,
-
Accessing high-quality learning affordably by doing it groups,
-
Getting support that complements other services, such as one-on-one mentoring,
-
Learning and collaborating with peers, so feeling less isolated.
In addition, the wider community benefits from:
-
More ventures, and more successful ventures,
-
Brining new skills, ideas and support, so building local service providers capability,
-
Increased export income (increased sales) or income retention (reduce leakage)
-
Retaining people and ventures that otherwise might leave to access the learning.
In the context of deliberately growing a functional ‘ecosystem’ of support for ventures. Learning programs are “one leg of the tripod” of Space, Community and Learning.
Without structured learning the culture within the community won’t have the sense of upward momentum and vertical drive, nor the practical means for ventures to skill-up and step-up to realise their inspiring visions.
Constraints in actual delivery of this type of learning in the regions centred around attracting people to the opportunities, building momentum and difficulty engaging enough innovators, startups or entrepreneurs. Catering for diverse audiences is necessary when in regional areas and dealing with small numbers, yet makes it hard to find content and market it in ways that appeal to both, say, startup, digital social enterprises and scale-up manufacturing companies
In addition, using learning programs as a revenue stream for the sustainability of incubators themselves is difficult. The challenge with offering innovation style learning in an early (maturity) region can mean small cohorts, and a suspicion around impact and importance, from ventures themselves, and those that financially support the learning programs (Government, partners). Input from Curtin University was interesting, there is a focus on trying to improve the measurement of effectiveness, impact and benefits post-program, considering ‘stackable’ credentials (i.e. short, sharp, bite-size learning, a menu to pick from), and a pathway between different programs for ventures through stages in the ecosystem. Noting that Universities have had to innovate and respond to emerging trends in learning preferences, programs offered are similar in style and duration to traditional incubator offerings such as accelerator programs (Curtin Ignition), which although adds competition to the market, the benefits of working with Universities in the wider ecosystem means someone is looking strategically at outcomes and impact, which isn’t always possible as a resource poor incubator or coworking space.
Perhaps the most insightful point raised was that ventures in the regions are truly isolated, often low populations mean less startups and entrepreneurs, and the opportunity to learn with others is the seed of great community.
So, there are many benefits to learning programs and the outcomes generally outweigh the investment required.
But, this is really a context-specific question, hence the different forms and number of learning programs in each community and region. One way incubators can match programs to needs in their region is to have clear goals, outcomes and indicators and evaluate the impact of learning programs on ventures. They can do this is by collecting data, not just ‘bums on seats’ but qualitative data on impact to individuals, following the trajectory of ventures (finding success, earlier, or failing, quicker with less investment lost), feedback direct from ventures on how it has helped them scale, grow, or succeed, and feedback from the wider ecosystem about how the learning program may have contributed to the community.
viagra 100mg usa – sildenafil 150mg pill order sildenafil 150mg generic
cheap viagra generic – order viagra 150mg pill buy viagra 100mg sale
order prednisolone pill – gabapentin 800mg drug cialis 20mg pill
prednisolone order online – gabapentin 100mg tablet tadalafil max dose
buy augmentin 375mg pill – cialis 5mg pill buy cialis 5mg generic
augmentin generic – genuine cialis buy tadalafil
bactrim 960mg pill – bactrim without prescription viagra next day
order bactrim 480mg – buy viagra 100mg for sale sildenafil 50mg pills
order cephalexin 500mg without prescription – erythromycin 500mg generic buy erythromycin pill
cephalexin cheap – order generic cephalexin 125mg erythromycin 250mg drug
purchase sildenafil generic – buy ivermectin 12mg buy stromectol 12mg
sildenafil 100mg pills – purchase fildena generic cost for ivermectin 3mg
buy generic rhinocort – buy tadalafil sale purchase antabuse pills
budesonide cheap – disulfiram generic brand disulfiram
cheap cefuroxime 250mg – order cefuroxime 500mg generic order tadalafil 10mg online
order ceftin 250mg – order cialis pills cialis 10mg us
ampicillin drug – cost ampicillin 250mg tadalafil 5mg
ampicillin cost – cipro 1000mg drug purchase cialis
cost amoxicillin – generic amoxil 1000mg vardenafil 20mg sale
buy amoxicillin 1000mg – vardenafil 10mg oral levitra 10mg us
ivermectin 4 tablets price – ivermectin 3mg stromectol order levitra 10mg
ivermectin cream 1 – levitra cheap order vardenafil 10mg
doxycycline 100mg price – order clomid 50mg pill tadalafil 10mg brand
cheap doxycycline 200mg – doxycycline 100mg tablet tadalafil online order
generic tadalafil 10mg – online pharmacy canadian buy generic modafinil 200mg
cost cialis 40mg – cialis black buy provigil pill
prednisone 20mg brand – order deltasone 10mg online cheap buy accutane 20mg
buy deltasone 20mg sale – isotretinoin 40mg canada buy isotretinoin 10mg online
buy amoxicillin 250mg for sale – buy amoxicillin without prescription viagra 150mg price
buy amoxicillin 250mg sale – purchase azithromycin for sale sildenafil pills 50mg
buy prednisolone 40mg online cheap – prednisolone 10mg for sale sildenafil mail order usa
order generic prednisolone – cost viagra 150mg viagra 50mg uk
buy furosemide 40mg generic – doxycycline drug buy stromectol uk
order lasix 40mg generic – doxycycline 100mg pills ivermectin 12 mg for humans for sale
purchase hydroxychloroquine generic – oral baricitinib 4mg baricitinib 2mg uk
order generic plaquenil 400mg – buy chloroquine 250mg without prescription baricitinib 2mg without prescription
purchase glucophage pill – norvasc order norvasc 5mg tablet
cheap lisinopril 10mg – atenolol 50mg without prescription cheap tenormin
generic lisinopril 10mg – order omeprazole 10mg generic atenolol 100mg tablet
brand vardenafil – buy clomiphene without prescription brand clomiphene 100mg
vardenafil medication – clomid cost order clomiphene without prescription
order albuterol 4mg generic – academicwriters dapoxetine 90mg without prescription
ventolin inhalator for sale online – help with essay writing purchase dapoxetine generic
cheap levothyroxine sale – synthroid 150mcg cost buy hydroxychloroquine 400mg pills
buy synthroid 100mcg pills – clarinex uk purchase plaquenil sale
oral cialis 10mg – sildenafil 100mg tablets viagra tablet
generic cialis – cialis 5mg tablet sildenafil pills 50mg
buy prednisone sale – xenical 120mg sale amoxicillin 500mg over the counter
buy prednisone 5mg without prescription – where to buy prednisone tablets amoxil 1000mg sale
brand diltiazem 180mg – diltiazem 180mg canada buy gabapentin 800mg
diltiazem online order – neurontin uk cost neurontin 100mg
order furosemide – zovirax uk doxycycline 200mg pills
furosemide oral – order zovirax 800mg cheap doxycycline 100mg
buy cenforce without prescription – buy domperidone pill order motilium 10mg pill
buy cenforce 50mg without prescription – buy ezetimibe generic buy motilium 10mg without prescription
sildenafil 200 mg – cialis 5mg drug cheap cialis generic
sildenafil oral – order tadalafil for sale tadalafil 40mg canada
provigil sale – order deltasone 5mg pills order rhinocort generic
modafinil 200mg brand – modafinil ca order rhinocort online
buy isotretinoin 10mg for sale – isotretinoin for sale tetracycline 500mg ca
isotretinoin buy online – cheap amoxil 500mg order generic tetracycline 250mg
buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg for sale – propranolol pill cheap inderal 10mg
buy cyclobenzaprine 15mg generic – colchicine 0.5mg ca inderal oral
buy clopidogrel online – order generic reglan 10mg metoclopramide 10mg sale