This is an fantastic paper from one of the world’s most prestigious economic research institutes: The Centre for Economic Performance.
One of three very useful conclusions for those running or supporting incubators is: “there is fairly clear evidence incubators and accelerators work overall – for survival, employment growth and receiving external finance”.
But rather than skip to conclusions I recommend reading from the start. The opening paragraph alone is as valuable as the conclusions, as it succinctly summarises the arguments for innovation and entrepreneurship. And it continues, throughout the rest of the article there are many very useful summaries and clarifications including: co-location as complementary to clustering, effects on job growths, whether female and minority participants disproportionately benefit, multiple perspectives on the rise of coworking and evidence for benefits of geographic (or other forms of) “proximities”.
The ‘What makes a good incubator?’ article seems a good complementary read, published around the same time and written without awareness of the CEP’s work on the similar topic. The CEP discussion paper asks deeper though similar questions (“we need to consider who benefits”) and answers them with academic rigour with a city or region-scale economic development perspective.
I especially appreciated the description of the evidence of the benefits of proximities. Several sources are cited in concluding that “real world knowledge spillovers exhibit substantial distance decay, especially for ‘knowledge-intensive’ services…and spillovers may disappear within 250m”. And more than just geographical, ‘proximities’ include social closeness (e.g. through friendship), organisational (e.g. working in the same firm), cognitive (e.g. the same subject background), or institutional proximity (e.g. common norms).
This evidence around proximities makes sense of the ‘feel’ one gets about incubators that are working or aren’t and the need for them to be ‘buzzing’, have ‘density’ or be ‘centres of gravity’. This sense of ‘proximity’ also seems fundamental to the quality of ‘designing for and accelerating serendipity’ as often cited by coworking advocates and explored in this Future Tense podcast.
A second (of three) final conclusions in the article opens nicely into not knowing and perhaps the limits of what can be known through this sort of study and research: “we have much less clarity about how programmes achieve results”. This is aligned with the GALI studies comments about the impacts of different program design.
That this discussion paper is so thorough and excellent demonstrates how sound foundations enable next questions. For example: knowing that incubators work generally, we can now ask how and for whom do they work specifically?
I suspect questions like that lend themselves a bit more to ethnography, intense studies of the micro-details of ‘customer journeys’ and investigating the micro-dynamics and value created in individual and aggregated human interactions within incubation situations.
That question and investigation isn’t just academic or of interest to public funders, but actually the daily concern of incubator and accelerator managers. It goes to the heart of what the best ‘hosts’ and incubator managers do: to in each interaction, feel for the alignment and contribution that will add value for the human in front of them, the venture, investor, incubator, city and community.
sildenafil 150mg price – sildenafil 150mg ca buy sildenafil 150mg pills
prednisolone 10mg sale – neurontin brand oral cialis 40mg
order augmentin 375mg generic – cialis 10mg brand guaranteed cialis overnight delivery usa
cheap bactrim 960mg – generic viagra 100mg viagra 100mg england
order cephalexin 500mg sale – buy generic erythromycin 500mg order erythromycin 500mg online
buy generic sildenafil 100mg – order fildena 100mg for sale ivermectin nz
order budesonide online – purchase rhinocort pill buy antabuse 500mg pills
order ceftin 250mg generic – methocarbamol over the counter buy cialis 10mg pill
cheap ampicillin 250mg – cialis 20mg drug cialis 5mg oral
amoxicillin 500mg usa – buy amoxicillin 1000mg online cheap buy vardenafil generic
stromectol for lice – ivermectin buy nz vardenafil 10mg for sale
buy generic doxycycline 200mg – cialis 20mg drug generic cialis canada
order cialis 10mg online – order tadalafil 20mg without prescription modafinil 100mg pills
buy prednisone 10mg for sale – ed remedies buy accutane for sale
buy amoxil 250mg online cheap – amoxil 1000mg uk cheap sildenafil sale
cheap prednisolone pill – buy generic sildenafil 150mg sildenafil cost
buy furosemide – ivermectin 6mg for sale ivermectin lotion price
buy plaquenil 200mg pill – aralen ca baricitinib pills
cheap glucophage – buy lipitor 10mg pills norvasc 5mg sale
lisinopril over the counter – order generic metoprolol 100mg order tenormin 100mg online
order vardenafil 20mg – buy generic levitra 10mg clomiphene 100mg pills
buy generic albuterol 2mg – ventolin buy online purchase priligy without prescription
synthroid 100mcg over the counter – cheap plaquenil purchase plaquenil for sale
cialis 20 – order cialis without prescription viagra cheap
order deltasone 10mg sale – prednisone 60mg pills amoxil canada
diltiazem 180mg over the counter – order azithromycin 250mg brand gabapentin
purchase furosemide online cheap – zovirax 800mg cost doxycycline 200mg without prescription
cenforce 100mg for sale – order crestor generic domperidone oral
cheap sildenafil 150mg – buy cialis 5mg buy tadalafil 5mg sale
modafinil 100mg over the counter – deltasone 40mg cost order rhinocort generic
accutane price – order amoxil without prescription tetracycline 500mg ca
flexeril price – order colchicine 0.5mg pill inderal over the counter
order plavix online – buy methotrexate 10mg generic buy reglan 10mg online