If you’re trying to change a system or build a new one, collaborating with like-minded people with aligned interests is a likely occurrence. Whether it’s growing the social enterprise ‘sector’, an ‘ecosystem’ of support for startups or government alliance to improve regional economic development, cooperating with others on advocacy, investment attraction and learning from each other makes sense.
These new alliances are often formed through frustration at current institutions or culture, a vision of something different and willingness to invest a a lot of intellect and energy in addressing it. However despite often being comprised of the brightest and most successful talent in a sector, success in ‘coalitions of the willing’ is far from assured. I’ve written previously about the conditions enabling of successful collaboration within alliances, and this post is to share share some insights into how these alliances can be effective in their mission and context.
First some background.
While Buckminster Fuller advises to avoid fighting then obsolete and existing, there’s a lot to be said for taking as much energy, resources, talent and money as you can from the old to grow the new. The success of attracting investment of energy or attention to the new depends on the ability of advocates to sell something to the old that doesn’t yet exist, is new and emerging. This education and sales process is often happening even while the old and obsolete is arguably at its peak: operating effectively with workable and enshrined rules, but where out-dated norms and institutions and vested interests dominate.
An example in Australia is that as our national attention shifts from selling commodities to attracting external investment in innovation. While existing institutions are still advocating on behalf of wealthy incumbents and their existing business models, new alliances are draw attention and money towards the next wave of ventures that will generate new export dollars and social benefits.
Each new alliance is their own ‘startup’, in a way: moving from the seed of an idea with governance, business model, legitimacy and effectiveness developing along the way to realising the intended impact, changing the system they work in. They are also arguably more complex than a startup, having multiple foci, markets, proposes and participants with different motivations, and and probably have the intention of disappearing or becoming less relevant once the transition is complete.
Given that context, here are eight insights into factors enabling of effectiveness and sustainability of alliances:
1. Shifting the Centre
Any new alliance must clearly represent a ‘movement’: a shift from one mindset than another, new types of organisations etc. The shift must be embodied and necessarily marginalise something that was previously central. You can’t convince others by pointing from afar, you must stand in the future model/mindset you are advocating for and invite others to shift their perspective or position. An example from the social enterprise sector would be peak representative bodies operating as social enterprises themselves.
2. Serve best by putting first
Effective alliances seem to need upfront investment and commitment by those with a primary interest in the health of the system, and a secondary financial or personal interest in its success. Waiting for government or someone else with power to invest in something affects the power dynamics and ability to realise the mission. The financial or personal interest can keep people with martyred tendencies motivated in moments of doubt, failure or frustration. An example from StartupWA is that Directors share a common ethos of wanting the sector to succeed, and also have jobs or lead organisations whose business model depends on that success.
3. Active listening
Effective alliances must be open, have direct mechanisms for incorporating feedback from others, and let those they represent that they’ve heard them. Claims of representation without hard-wired mechansims for democratic election, consultation or deliberation is probably ego-aggrandisement. Whether a structure like an incorporated association, open democratic elections of Directors, regular stakeholder forums or annual ‘ecosystem reports’ the leaders must actively seek guidance from those they serve, confirm they’ve heard it, especially if they don’t agree with or like it.
4. Redirecting returns
Investment in these alliances should be conditional on the degree to which they attract and redirect investment into others they represent. The founders of such networks are often charming, intelligence and skilful with their own marginal business models, and a test for them and supporters is how much of that talent actually translates into cash, policies or opportunities for those the claim to serve. An example from Pollinators is that we generally prioritise supporting crowdfunding campaigns for member’s ventures and outsourcing contract opportunities to members to deliver over fundraising for ourselves or growing our core staff team.
5. Measuring progress
Clear metrics and measures of success that are openly reported and to which the organisations are held to account. Without clarity on the facts and metrics of progress alliances can become decided about their own importance and impact, making them unable to share, learn and grow. An example is that CBRIN produces fantastic and detailed annual reports that support the annual multi-million dollar investment into the network. From an outside perspective, this is very powerful in enabling objective assessment of their effectiveness and merit.
6. Influencing over directing
They seek to influence power, not wield it directly. Influencing is essential and enables an independent stance from government or corporate power. Actually being in a position of power to direct funding, investment or policy is a completely different role, dynamic and the primary purpose of an alliance. If an alliance seeks to control funding, investment or policy directly, I would be suspicious of their motives, primary allegiances or ability to succeed long-term.
7. Avoiding cannibalism
Alliances must discover a business model that doesn’t compete or cannibalise others in the ecosystem. It’s relatively easy to get money from business leaders and bureacrats for a shiny new ‘meta’ initiative that promises a lot and looks great as an adornment and endorsement of the legitimacy of the institution. However, actually figuring out a long-term value proposition that keeps the alliance independent while also in close relationship with stakeholders is very, very tricky. This is especially the case because alliance member’s own model may be marginal; they could compete for the same money or resources as the alliance itself, and there may already be other membership-based or sponsor-funded initiatives in the same sector or geography.
8. Learning collectively
As well connected, well informed and bright the alliance members may be, chance are when you get them together to talk they will each learn something new as well as learning collectively. By their very nature these alliances are guiding something new and emerging, there’s honestly lot of ‘not knowing’ and so must be investment in learning from mistakes, sharing insights from other similar alliances, and anticipating collective challenges. So, investment in collective catch-ups and reflective conversations are essential.
If you have feedback, comments or find this useful. I’d love to know, just comment below of get in touch via Twitter @ArOuthwaite
—
These insights and opinions are my own, taken from leading, following or involvement in:
- Pollinators Inc – started as a growing community of social entrepreneurs and now a standout network, coworking space and social enterprise in regional Australia. I co-founded the organisation.
- StartupWA – formed to advance the startup economy in WA and structured as a NFP Company Limited by Guarantee, inspired by StartupAus and similar intiatives in other states. I’m a Director.
- Greater Geraldton Governance Alliance – formed to collaborate on regional economic development and structured as a committee of the local government. Disclosure: I was deputy chairperson.
- Social Innovation, Entrepreneurship and Enterprise Alliance – a coalition of 15 social enterprise incubators and consultants and structured as a ‘constellation’ model of governance. I represented Pollinators in this alliance.
- Canberra Innovation Network – formed to suppport and promote innovation in Canberra and a NFP with charity status, and publishing transparent reports on its achievements and operations. I just like what they do, from afar.
- TechSydney – recently announced as an alliance of the top tech companies in Sydney to replicate the success of Silicon Valley, and sparking interesting online commentary and discussion about its merits. Just interested in how they form.
- Progress Midwest – an emerging initiative spun out of Mid West Development Commission, City of Greater Geraldton and an network of organisations suppporting business. I represent Pollinators in the supporting network.
Thanks Andrew, this is really useful. As we form the “alliance” of Yoga for Pain Care Australia I will make sure we pay careful attention to this guidance.
order sildenafil generic – pfizer viagra 50mg buy viagra 100mg
sildenafil 25mg price – viagra pill cheapest viagra
purchase prednisolone online – gabapentin 800mg usa buy cialis 10mg for sale
cheap prednisolone sale – tadalafil pill buy cialis 20mg without prescription
augmentin pills – order augmentin 1000mg online generic cialis 20mg
order augmentin 625mg pills – female cialis us pharmacy cialis
sulfamethoxazole price – buy viagra pill sildenafil 100mg canada
bactrim 960mg cost – buy viagra without prescription viagra overnight shipping
cephalexin 125mg sale – purchase erythromycin online cheap erythromycin price
buy cephalexin 500mg online – buy cleocin 300mg order erythromycin 500mg pill
order sildenafil – cost nolvadex 10mg ivermectin covid
generic fildena – purchase sildenafil pills ivermectin where to buy
rhinocort without prescription – disulfiram 500mg oral disulfiram 250mg uk
order budesonide pills – cialis usa antabuse 250mg canada
buy cefuroxime 250mg – tadalafil drug purchase cialis sale
cost cefuroxime 500mg – buy robaxin 500mg cost cialis 10mg
ampicillin for sale – cost ampicillin cialis 40mg cost
acillin pills – ciprofloxacin pills order cialis 10mg online cheap
amoxil 250mg without prescription – amoxil 250mg canada vardenafil 10mg pill
purchase amoxicillin online cheap – amoxil 250mg canada order vardenafil 20mg generic
ivermectin 250ml – vardenafil pills levitra 20mg sale
stromectol xl – ivermectin 12mg online oral levitra
generic doxycycline 100mg – cialis cheap tadalafil otc
order doxycycline 100mg generic – order doxycycline 200mg pill tadalafil 40mg canada
levitra or cialis – best online pharmacy canada cost provigil 100mg
buy cialis 40mg generic – cost provigil 100mg buy modafinil 200mg pill
order deltasone 40mg sale – deltasone 5mg pill buy accutane online cheap
deltasone tablet – generic isotretinoin accutane 40mg drug
buy amoxil 500mg sale – buy amoxicillin 500mg sale sildenafil overnight shipping usa
amoxicillin 250mg generic – zithromax medication sildenafil cheap
buy prednisolone 40mg without prescription – buy gabapentin for sale buy viagra 100mg sale
order prednisolone online cheap – sildenafil price viagra sildenafil 25mg
order furosemide pill – buy doxycycline generic ivermectin 1 cream generic
lasix order – price of stromectol buy ivermectin for humans
plaquenil 200mg tablet – buy baricitinib generic purchase baricitinib without prescription
order plaquenil 400mg pills – order chloroquine 250mg online buy baricitinib 2mg pills
order metformin 500mg generic – lipitor without prescription buy amlodipine 10mg generic
buy glucophage for sale – purchase atorvastatin generic amlodipine online
order lisinopril 2.5mg without prescription – order lisinopril pill buy tenormin 100mg without prescription
buy lisinopril 10mg generic – buy lisinopril 2.5mg pills buy tenormin 100mg generic
buy vardenafil 20mg – medrol 4mg tablets order clomiphene sale
levitra 20mg without prescription – clomid price clomiphene 100mg brand
buy ventolin inhalator without prescription – help with writing a paper purchase priligy online cheap
albuterol order online – best casino slot games buy dapoxetine generic
buy synthroid without prescription – buy levothyroxine generic buy plaquenil 400mg online cheap
order synthroid 150mcg without prescription – purchase aristocort online buy hydroxychloroquine online cheap
tadalafil 40mg price – viagra 100 mg viagra 50 mg
brand tadalafil 10mg – purchase tadalafil generic sildenafil us
order prednisone 10mg pills – accutane pills order online cheap amoxil generic
buy deltasone pill – accutane order online usa buy amoxicillin 250mg without prescription
buy diltiazem 180mg – azithromycin 500mg generic brand neurontin 800mg
buy diltiazem pill – buy neurontin 600mg sale order neurontin 100mg without prescription
purchase furosemide online – lasix order cost doxycycline
lasix canada – zyloprim 100mg price doxycycline 200mg uk
cenforce 50mg canada – crestor online buy order domperidone 10mg online cheap
cenforce 50mg usa – buy cenforce 100mg generic domperidone without prescription
viagra 50mg for sale – cheap cialis without prescription generic cialis cost
order viagra 150mg – tadalafil pill female cialis cvs
oral modafinil 200mg – order budesonide generic budesonide allergy spray
order provigil 100mg for sale – purchase rhinocort without prescription budesonide pills
accutane price – buy amoxicillin without prescription tetracycline 500mg without prescription
accutane medication – amoxil over the counter order tetracycline online cheap
order cyclobenzaprine 15mg for sale – buy ketorolac pills propranolol ca
purchase flexeril online – order inderal 20mg online order inderal 10mg sale
plavix ca – buy warfarin 5mg pills reglan 20mg drug